This site is a work in progress and has not been widely shared. Content may contain errors. Feedback is welcome.
This site is undergoing review. Some annotations were human-generated, some AI-generated — all are being verified.
Back to papers

Exposure to Generative Artificial Intelligence in the European Labour Market

Nurski, Ruer

2024Bruegel Working Paper1 citations
Exposure / measurement
LLM / Generative AI
Abstract

We apply two sets of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) occupational exposure scores - one task-based, one ability-based - to the European Labour Force Survey. While using different methodologies, our findings reveal consistent demographic patterns across the two approaches: jobs held by women, highly educated and younger workers are more exposed to GenAI technology in Europe. We also review the literature on the recent productivity impact of GenAI. Within the same occupations, less-experienced or less-skilled workers consistently get the largest productivity gains from GenAI support. We argue that a task-based analysis is more fruitful than an ability-based one, both for guiding GenAI adoption in organisations and their workplaces, and for assessing the employment and job quality impact on workers. Finally, we provide policy recommendations that can help workers (ie the labour supply) adjust to technological disruption, such as providing training and social safety nets. But we go further by also suggesting policy interventions that could redirect future labour demand towards better jobs, by promoting job redesign and organisational agility. Monitoring GenAI's employment effects and researching the 'jagged technological frontier' is necessary to further build our understanding of the employment impact of this transformational technology.

Summary

Nurski and Ruer construct a generative AI exposure measure for European occupations to study labor market exposure patterns across European countries

Main Finding

European labor markets show significant variation in exposure to generative AI across occupations and countries

Primary Datasets

European Labour Force Survey; European occupation and task data

Secondary Datasets

None

Key Methods
Construction of generative AI exposure measure for European occupations using task-based approach
Sample Period
2024
Geographic Coverage
Europe
Sample Size
European labor force across multiple countries
Level of Analysis
Occupation, Country
Occupation Classification
European occupation classification
Notes
Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024 [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024. [Claude classification]: WARNING: Paper content extraction failed - only journal headers visible. Classification based on title, authors, and working paper series information only. Requires verification with actual paper content. Bruegel Working Paper 06/2024.