This site is a work in progress and has not been widely shared. Content may contain errors. Feedback is welcome.
This site is undergoing review. Some annotations were human-generated, some AI-generated — all are being verified.
Back to papers

Tasks, Automation, and the Rise in US Wage Inequality

Acemoglu, Restrepo

2021NBER Working Paper Series101 citations
Observational labor marketTheoretical model
Automation / RobotsRoutine Task ChangeSkills & TasksAugmentation vs. substitution
Abstract

We document that between 50% and 70% of changes in the U.S. wage structure over the last four decades are accounted for by relative wage declines of worker groups specialized in routine tasks in industries experiencing rapid automation. We develop a conceptual framework where tasks across industries are allocated to different types of labor and capital. Automation technologies expand the set of tasks performed by capital, displacing certain worker groups from jobs for which they have comparative advantage. This framework yields a simple equation linking wage changes of a demographic group to the task displacement it experiences. We report robust evidence in favor of this relationship and show that regression models incorporating task displacement explain much of the changes in education wage differentials between 1980 and 2016. The negative relationship between wage changes and task displacement is unaffected when we control for changes in market power, deunionization, and other forms of capital deepening and technology unrelated to automation. We also propose a methodology for evaluating the full general equilibrium effects of automation, which incorporate induced changes in industry composition and ripple effects due to task reallocation across different groups. Our quantitative evaluation explains how major changes in wage inequality can go hand‐in‐hand with modest productivity gains.

Summary

Acemoglu and Restrepo develop a task-based framework and use US Census and industry data from 1980-2016 to study how automation-driven task displacement affects wage inequality across demographic groups defined by education, gender, age, and race.

Main Finding

Between 50% and 70% of changes in US wage structure from 1980-2016 are explained by relative wage declines of worker groups specialized in routine tasks in industries experiencing rapid automation, with groups facing 25% task displacement experiencing approximately 40% relative wage decline.

Primary Datasets

Census; CPS; DOT; O*NET

Secondary Datasets

International Federation of Robotics (IFR); BLS Multifactor Productivity Tables; Feenstra-Hanson offshoring data; Chinese import competition data (Acemoglu et al. 2016); CPS unionization data; Compustat; De Loecker et al. (2020) markup estimates

Key Methods
Task displacement decomposition combining industry labor share declines with worker specialization in routine occupations; structural estimation of propagation matrix capturing ripple effects; general equilibrium calibration quantifying direct and indirect effects of automation
Sample Period
1980-2016
Geographic Coverage
US
Sample Size
500 demographic groups covering US workforce; 49 industries consistently tracked 1987-2016
Level of Analysis
Individual, Occupation, Industry
Occupation Classification
Census/O*NET-SOC
Industry Classification
49 NAICS industries aggregated from BEA data
Notes
Econometrica; 50-70% of wage structure changes from task displacement [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement. [Claude classification]: Published version appeared in Econometrica. Paper develops novel task displacement framework distinct from SBTC. Uses robot adoption from IFR and software/specialized machinery adoption from BLS as instruments for task displacement. Finds automation explains 50-70% of wage structure changes while generating only 3.8% TFP growth. General equilibrium analysis incorporates ripple effects via estimated propagation matrix. Task displacement concentrated in middle of wage distribution, contributing to polarization. Markups, concentration, import competition, and deunionization play minimal role conditional on task displacement.